ENTERPRISE

Group Test – Soundbars (Part 1)

4/16/2013 11:34:23 AM

Fed-up with inferior flat screen sound? Improve your sonic satisfaction with an affordable sound bar solution

It’s visual appeal that counts most when buying a TV, from the slinkiness of the frame to the eye-popping quality of the HD images. In the quest to make screens ever thinner and less physically imposing audio remains very much an after-though. Consequently, the sound quality from built-in TV speakers is not much better than the radio cassette player in a 1970s’ Ford Cortina. No flat screen on the planet wouldn’t benefit from a bit of sonic stimulation.

A sound bar is the simplest way of getting aurally sorted but the market is complex. Factors that need to be considered include connectivity, format handling, power output and whether or not you want a separate subwoofer. The latter can make a substantial difference to your enjoyment and the trend of r wirelessly connected subs makes it a lot easier to keep your living room looking neat and tidy. The physical size of a sound bar can be critical if you’re intending to use it on a TV stand rather than use a wall-mount. As for connectivity, hi-res audio decoding requires HDMI inputs, a feature beyond the scope of this test, but not a fatal omission, given that by their very nature sound bars can’t deliver a genuine 7.1 sound field. Also, all of these models can still handle Dolby Digital and DTS digital surround sound formats.

This test consists of four models ranging in price from $225 to $525 and our aim was to find out how performance and convenience vary across that fiscal spectrum. We put the bars through their sonic paces by using a range of test material including the viscerally exciting DTS-HD tracks of Band of Brothers and Twilight, Mozart’s sublime Violin Concerto in D Minor, a DTS recording of Talking Heads’ thumping Life During Wartime and a selection of TV broadcasts on Sky.

Buying tips

The height of a sound bar can be critical when mounting it on the same stand as your TV. Too tall and it may impinge on the visibility of your screen

Always ask for a demonstration, which will show that manufacturer claims about power output can be taken with a cellar-full of salt

Check the digital connections. Optical inputs are common on sound bars, whilst coaxial outputs dominate Blu-ray decks

Bose solo TV sound system

Bose solo TV sound system

Bose solo TV sound system

Ratings

Plus

·         Simple to use

·         Can be used as a base under a TV stand

·         Copes well without a sub

Minus

·         Only one input allowed at a time

·         Better at music than movies

·         Footprint too small for many TVs

·         Build: 8 stars

·         Setup: 9 stars

·         Performance: 8 stars

·         Features: 7 stars

·         Value: 7 stars

·         Overall: 78%

Strictly speaking, the Solo is not a sound bar, due to its shape. In terms of functionality, it is nothing but.

You can’t help but think that Bose’s decision to design the Solo in the shape of a (rather ordinary looking) deck or PVR is both inspired and flawed. Inspired because it means a TV can be placed directly on its top surface, flawed because many TV stands have larger footprints than the Solo’s dimensions (51cm wide x 26cm deep).

Features-wise the Solo is a simple proposition but like the Orbitsound, it impresses by offering a coaxial audio input as well as optical and stereo analogue phonos. However, our joy is tempered slightly by the fact that you can only have one input physically hooked up at a time. User information and operation is typical Bose minimalism, with just a single LED light that glows and blinks according to the unit’s status. The remote control has only four buttons, for controlling power and volume.

With no subwoofer, no display on the fascia, no DSP modes, and no way of adjusting the quality of the sound the Solo is aimed at the armchair enthusiast who simply wants a better sound and doesn’t want to spend time playing around with setting according to the source. It’s a risky strategy but is not without merit, especially when the results are as good as they are here/

The battle scene of Narnia is engaging and the Bose produces plenty of low-end grunts. In Band of Brothers there’s a strong sense of refinement and dialogue has good clarity. In both movies certain high-end effects sound a little clipped, such as sword clashes and bullet swooshes. The dialogue of Mad Men is rich and satisfying.

Musically, the Solo really gets going, taking Talking Head’s tricky Life During Wartime in its stride, surprisingly keeping a lid on the thump of the drum-heavy mix.

LG NB3520A

Ratings

Plus

·         Versatile but easy to use

·         Generally impressive audio

·         USB and Bluetooth playback

Minus

·         Different sources require tweaking

·         Not so adept at music

·         Artificial sound

·         Build: 8 stars

·         Setup: 8 stars

·         Performance: 7 stars

·         Features: 9 stars

·         Value: 8 stars

·         Overall: 80%

LG’s NB3520A is reassuringly solid and attractive which is just what a sound bar should be. At 8cm tall, it fits neatly under most flat screen TVs even on a tabletop, but its 100cm width may look odd with smaller screens and be too wide for some TV stands.

LG NB3520A

LG NB3520A

It’s more convenient than a corner shop, offering a wireless sub, which can be tucked away behind the sofa and handily connects to the sound bar of its own volition. There is also playback of MP3s from USB flash drives and streaming from Bluetooth devices. This model may lack HDMI (and hence high resolution DTS HD MA decoding) but that’s acceptable at this price, and compensation comes in the form of dual optical inputs as well as a 3.5mm jack. Double optical inputs mean you can take advantage of surround sound decoding from say a Sky box or TV as well as a DVD or Blu-ray deck.

LG’s NB3520A is reassuringly solid and attractive which is just what a soundbar should be

LG’s NB3520A is reassuringly solid and attractive which is just what a sound bar should be

The remote control is chunky by sound bar standards but well laid out and packed with buttons. An LED display on the sound bar itself clearly indicates the playback and mode status, with eight DSP modes available. It’s worth playing with these, as well as adjusting the subwoofer level and trying the (pseudo) 3D effect button as the NB3520A is more than capable of delivering excellent sound. It seems more at home with movies and drama than music, thanks to its pit-bull of a subwoofer that draws up to 26W of power at times. Band of Brothers’ cacophonous DTS soundtrack is immensely powerful, yet nicely controlled so that dialogue remains clear and bullets whizz around energetically and distinctly. With music the subwoofer need reigning in from swamping the mid-range with Talking Heads’ Life During Wartime. Mozart’s Violin Concerto in D Major by Marianne Thorsen is bright and lively but remains a tad artificial. Bluetooth and USB playback are both pleasingly simple to set up and operate but it struggles to smooth over the cracks in inferior MP3 music files.

Other  
 
Top 10
Extending LINQ to Objects : Writing a Single Element Operator (part 2) - Building the RandomElement Operator
Extending LINQ to Objects : Writing a Single Element Operator (part 1) - Building Our Own Last Operator
3 Tips for Maintaining Your Cell Phone Battery (part 2) - Discharge Smart, Use Smart
3 Tips for Maintaining Your Cell Phone Battery (part 1) - Charge Smart
OPEL MERIVA : Making a grand entrance
FORD MONDEO 2.0 ECOBOOST : Modern Mondeo
BMW 650i COUPE : Sexy retooling of BMW's 6-series
BMW 120d; M135i - Finely tuned
PHP Tutorials : Storing Images in MySQL with PHP (part 2) - Creating the HTML, Inserting the Image into MySQL
PHP Tutorials : Storing Images in MySQL with PHP (part 1) - Why store binary files in MySQL using PHP?
REVIEW
- First look: Apple Watch

- 3 Tips for Maintaining Your Cell Phone Battery (part 1)

- 3 Tips for Maintaining Your Cell Phone Battery (part 2)
VIDEO TUTORIAL
- How to create your first Swimlane Diagram or Cross-Functional Flowchart Diagram by using Microsoft Visio 2010 (Part 1)

- How to create your first Swimlane Diagram or Cross-Functional Flowchart Diagram by using Microsoft Visio 2010 (Part 2)

- How to create your first Swimlane Diagram or Cross-Functional Flowchart Diagram by using Microsoft Visio 2010 (Part 3)
Popular Tags
Microsoft Access Microsoft Excel Microsoft OneNote Microsoft PowerPoint Microsoft Project Microsoft Visio Microsoft Word Active Directory Biztalk Exchange Server Microsoft LynC Server Microsoft Dynamic Sharepoint Sql Server Windows Server 2008 Windows Server 2012 Windows 7 Windows 8 Adobe Indesign Adobe Flash Professional Dreamweaver Adobe Illustrator Adobe After Effects Adobe Photoshop Adobe Fireworks Adobe Flash Catalyst Corel Painter X CorelDRAW X5 CorelDraw 10 QuarkXPress 8 windows Phone 7 windows Phone 8 BlackBerry Android Ipad Iphone iOS