When Microsoft announced its upcoming rival
to the iPad, Surface, the feature that seemed to get people most excited was
the keyboard built into its snap-on case.
‘Apple must be wishing it had thought of
that/ remarked the PC press, shrewdly.
What Apple understands, though, is that
just because you think of something, that doesn’t mean you have to do it.
Not everyone who buys an iPad needs a
keyboard case. But if you do, there are plenty of companies who’ll be happy to
sell you one. And that means you get to choose from around a dozen options, not
just two.
We tested six of the most promising models,
from big names and less familiar makers. So now you’ll know which to buy, with
the money you saved when your iPad didn’t come with one that you didn’t want.
Wish you’d thought of that, Microsoft?
Logitech
Ultrathin Keyboard Cover
Price: $142.4
From logitech.com/en-gb
Key points
It’s, um, ultra thin
Logitech has taken a slightly different approach
with its Ultrathin keyboard case. Rather than a folio that makes your iPad look
like an anonymous executive folder, the Ultrathin is more like an Apple Smart
Cover with a keyboard attached. However, instead of a flappy lightweight
plastic structure, the Logitech has a solid base to protect your iPad’s
precious screen.
Like the other models on test, the keyboard
connects via Bluetooth and contains a rechargeable battery; Logitech claims
this will last for six months between charges based on two hours of typing a
day. We didn’t quite have the time to test that fully, but with average use we
don’t doubt it.
Your iPad is held magnetically in the
trench across the top of the keyboard, and although we had doubts about this
scheme, in use it’s excellent. The base and iPad feel incredibly sturdy in this
configuration and it makes for a very good typing experience. The single
viewing angle might not appeal to all - especially if you’re in an awkward
position on a train or plane - but that’s a minor gripe.
The Logitech is an excellent keyboard and,
as the name promises, very thin and light. If you’re looking for something that
protects your iPad completely, this probably isn’t for you, since it gives just
the bare minimum of coverage. But as a handy portable keyboard it’s excellent.
Kensington
KeyFolio Expert
Price: $159.98
From
kensington.com
Key point
Nice angles - but watch you don’t tip it out
Now, here’s an idea. How would you like to
stick your iPad into a case, quite literally? Kensington has come up with the
idea that, rather than fiddle with a plastic clip-in solution or a fabric case
that you slip your iPad into, it would be more convenient just to use a sticky
pad. We saw something similar with the Cocon protective case last issue
(Macllser, 22 June 2012, p43), but that combined gel pads with a full surround
to keep your iPad in place. Here - well, it’s interesting. You align your iPad
with the sticky oblong and press firmly until it grabs on. The surface that
adheres to the iPad’s rear is multi-use, so you can attach and remove it as
many times as you like.
The keyboard itself is large, and the case
allows for a good selection of viewing angles. The case wraps around your iPad
and is both thin and lightweight; our only criticism is that it’s all flaps and
creases, making it difficult to quickly grab your iPad and move on.
The main advantages of the Kensington are
the multiple angles provided for by the sectioned case and the nicely
proportioned keyboard. However, we have reservations about the attachment
system. We never felt completely safe carrying the iPad in the KeyFolio,
especially as the open ends mean it could theoretically slide out as you move
about. You have to put a lot of faith in that sticky patch.
