Tradition dictates that all dictation
software reviews are dictated using the application itself, which is just what
we doing here [sic]. Although the copy will be edited to fit before you read it
in the magazine, we’ll keep it as close as possible to the raw results and note
any corrections we had to make.
Nuance claims that Dragon Dictate for Mac 3
is 15% more accurate than version two, and that’s noticeable in use. You can
still change the emphasis between recognition speed and accuracy, but even with
that emphasis set almost entirely in favour of speed, the results are very
convincing indeed, as you can see.
Dragon
Dictate For Mac 3
The training process takes around five
minutes and builds a sound profile that combines the acoustic characteristics
of your chosen input device and your own particular voice. This is improved as
you continue to use the product and correct any mistakes or misrecognized words
during your regular dictation.
The built-in dictionary knows all about
accurate capitalisation of brand names such as iPhone, iPad and iPod, and it
isn’t necessary to pause when you want to use acronyms like IBM, IT V and HSBC.
There’s some irony, then, that it insists on leaving out the space between the
words Dragon and Dictate in its own name [corrected here for style].
It knows that OS X has an X on the end
[despite being pronounced ‘ten’] and it knows the difference between similar
words that are used in different contexts. For example, without touching the
keyboard, I can accurately dictate that I know where to buy something to wear
this evening. I could use it to tell you whether the weather will be fine, and
it knows that while you ‘read’ a book, you would find ‘reeds’ growing in a
pond. It also knows where and when to use apostrophes correctly. All of this is
very impressive and means you can quite happily dictate long tracts of text
without having to keep to [too] close an eye on the screen.
THERE ARE BUILT-IN commands for searching Google, Bing, Yahoo [Dragon joins many a
competent subeditor in refusing to write ‘Yahoo!’] and Spotlight, and you can even
control the mouse so long as you are patient. A mouse grid command overlays the
screen with a 3 × 3 grid. You tell Dragon Dictate which square to click in, and
it does, further sub-dividing that square. Carry on like this until you’ve
isolated the point on the screen that you wanted, and drag and it will cricket
for you [um, that is, click it for you].
We were testing Dragon Dictate for Mac 3
Mobile, which not only includes a bundled headset microphone that plugs into
your USB port and is automatically recognized by OS X, but also a small
Phillips voice recorder [actually made by Philips, the Dutch electronics
company, not Phillips, the originator of the crosshead screw]. This can be set
to record MP3s, which Dragon Dictate can transcribe as though you are speaking
them live. The process is simple: pick Transcribe from the menus, point it at
the audio file, and watch as the words appear on screen, usually in faster than
real-time. The first time you use it, it will ask you to confirm that it has
accurately recognised your recorded words, and your original audio file is used
as the training method for this input type.
Version
3 is appreciably faster than the previous release, and it supports [a] wider
range of applications
Obviously, you can’t correct any mistakes
that it makes in transcribing your file as it works through it the way you can
when dictating live, when you can literally tell dictate [by which we meant
Dictate] how to step back and make an amendment still without touching the key
board or mouse. You might therefore have to spend a little more time polishing
it up once the transcription has been processed.
Version 3 is appreciably faster than the
previous release, and it supports [a] wider range of applications, thanks to
its Express Editor that you dictate into text fields for which it would
otherwise not have full text control. It’s most likely that this would be of
use to those with motor or visual impairment for whom dictation software is an
assistive product that helps them use a Mac.
Do you need Dragon Dictate when OS X now
has dictation built in? Perhaps not if you find dictation [that is, Dictation]
always works well for you and you always have an internet connection available,
without which it doesn’t work. Dragon is more trainable, and therefore likely
to be more accurate in the long term, and it lets you correct mistakes easily
by voice without resorting to the keyboard. Ironically, it also lets you
control your Mac by voice, for example opening applications by name, in ways
that OS X doesn’t.
Dragon Dictate for Mac 2 was already very
good, and remains so. It may be a little slower than this update, but if you’ve
been using it for some months or years – you’ll probably find that it has
reached a level of accuracy that isn’t far off what version 3 provides out of
the box. In that case, the £80 upgrade fee starts to look a little steep, and
unless you need to access applications that version two can’t address directly,
you may do better to stick with what you’ve already got.
But this release is extremely impressive
and worth the admittedly steep asking price if you don’t already have Dragon
Dictate.
Information
Ratings: 4/5
Price: $129
|